Hornbill Unleashed

February 2, 2010

Aliens in East Malaysia

Filed under: Human rights,Politics — Hornbill Unleashed @ 12:01 AM
Tags: , , , ,

By Sim Kwang Yang

TO those in the Klang Valley who read papers like The Star and The New Straits Times, Sabah must sound like the remote edge of the nation. It is out there, a huge chunk of real estate inhabited by exotic people speaking a strange version of Bahasa Malaysia.

Therefore, it would not be so clear to those participating in the national narrative why Sabahans make such a big deal about illegal immigrants. Are they not in all corners of the nation, numbering in the millions, working in jobs deemed neither lucrative nor respectable enough by Malaysian citizens?

Unfortunately, the national narrative does not always take into account the meek voices of Sabahans. Their problems are often considered too parochial to be of national concern.

Ask any Sabahan though, and he or she will tell you that there is no greater security and social problem facing Sabah today than that of illegal aliens. It is a daily nightmare that Sabahans have to live through and watch helplessly as it reels out of control.
Exactly how many illegal immigrants there are in Sabah is anybody’s guess. I have been told by a friend from Sabah that one in every two persons in the state could be an illegal alien.

Immigrant facts and figures

Recently, Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) deputy president and Member of Parliament (MP) for Sepanggar Datuk Eric Majimbun expressed shock at discovering a MyKad bearing his surname and address.

He was shocked because the card belonged to a Filipino illegal immigrant.

According to news reports, Majimbun said based on the 1970-2000 census, the population in Sabah increased from 636,431 to 2,449,389 (285%) over 30 years. Compare this with Sarawak’s 106% (from 976,269 to 2,012,616) and Peninsula Malaysia’s 113% (from 10,439,430 to 22,202,614).

He also queried census conducted by the government in Sabah, which showed a 236% increase in the Kadazandusun population between 1960 and 2000. For other bumiputera, it increased by 631%.

The figures tell the story. In Sabah, as in Sarawak, the Malay/Muslim population forms a small minority, an anomaly within the context of Malay dominance demanded by the nationalist narrative of Umno. The politics of race is the politics of counting heads, and by that logic, the chief minister of Sabah cannot be a Malay leader.

The rumour that has been going round in Sabah for decades is that certain politicians have been facilitating an increase in the Muslim population. These politicians allegedly engineer the issuance of Malaysian identity cards to illegal immigrants from the Muslim south of the Philippines and neighbouring Indonesia. This would dilute and therefore marginalise the political significance of the non-Muslim Kadazandusun people of Sabah.

Permanent resident status

Whenever there is uproar in Kota Kinabalu about the dangerous presence of these illegal immigrants, the federal government sends in a task force of sorts. A few thousand of these aliens are then deported. When the furore dies down, these deported foreigners can re-enter Sabah by the next boat or ferry.

To add insult to injury, native Sabahans who try to replace their old ICs with MyKad have been demoted to permanent resident status. This denies them the chance to even vote.

I have been to Sabah many times. In cities and suburbs, there are pockets with almost exclusive Filipino populations that sound, look, and smell more like a slum in Manila or Zamboanga than a piece of Malaysian soil.

For Sabahans, the massive and ubiquitous presence of these illegal immigrants feels like an alien growth in their body. Being so muted and so far away, their unease is not shared by Malaysians elsewhere.

The gravity of this issue drove the SAPP to threaten a vote of no confidence in the prime minister, and subsequently it pulled out of the Barisan Nasional (BN). Recently, even United Pasokmomogun Kazadandusun Murut Organisation leaders have been echoing this unhappiness with the central government.

Finally, the deputy president of Parti Bersatu Sabah (PBS), Datuk Dr Maximus Ongkili, announced that Sabah BN component parties would get to the bottom of the issue. What he omitted to say was that the massive and long-standing problem of illegal immigrants cannot be solved without focused political will from Kuala Lumpur.

Solutions and preoccupations

The obvious step to take is the establishment of a royal commission of enquiry specifically designed to investigate all aspects of this issue. This should include a thorough vetting of the National Registration Department in Sabah from top to bottom, as well as any political linkage that might exist in this burgeoning problem.

Unfortunately for Sabahans, the people in the power centre in Kuala Lumpur are all too busy with their party elections. They are also busy putting out sporadic fires on the economic front. Nothing can be further from their mind than the daily problems faced by distant, remote and inconsequential Sabahans.

That is all the reason needed for Sabahan MPs to jump ship and join Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s coalition. Provided, of course, Anwar can promise and deliver a comprehensive plan to weed out the illegal immigrants from the Land Below the Wind once and for all.

Without a change of government at the federal level, both Sarawak and Sabah cannot enjoy the fruits of federalism.



  1. […] the hell is happening lately says a concerned Sarawakian..? audie61 crew reminded him we are all Malaysians though but Natasha ,Joey and Cindy […]

    Pingback by Erm Ooops “Jual tubuh” « Audie61’s Weblog — February 2, 2010 @ 11:40 PM | Reply

  2. Don’t blame that Peninsular PM who encouraged this inflow of Muslim immigrants. Why did the local leaders allowed this to happen? Ask PBS and all the Christian leaders. Why are they still supporting BN? Then why complain?

    Comment by Sam01 — February 2, 2010 @ 8:43 PM | Reply

  3. All recommendations are welcome into getting rid of the menace. It will overun if not already, the local entity.
    There seemed to be so much effort and no result.
    Nothing, yes practically no movement at all even from the effort from migs.sabah, twenty point agreement(Sarawak’s 18 points), and all the efforts of calling for this and calling for that.
    We in Sabah n Sarawak are the “fixed deposit”. West Malaysian do not deny it. They subdue us for our weaknesses. We had grown and can flex the muscles now, physically and mentally.
    We need to combined resources and formed a focus factor to address the situation or the situation will addressed us, if it had not already done.
    Where shall we start?
    When to start?
    Who will/can be the panel?
    How to do it without being ISAed?

    “Sabah/Sarawak Incorporated” is a need. The combined force will call the shots. We are the king maker now. Why kowtow more?. Have we not seen enough?. Want to see more until……….
    When will they(West Malaysian) stop?
    When we are going to stop them?. It has to stop and to stop we must and now.
    Strike while the iron is hot. Lest it gets cool down so many times and will do so again.
    Invite think tanks from the masses and come up with a momentum as direction is already there. Start small to avoid this and that.
    Its easier said than done. At least its being said waiting to be done. We have done our social obligation.
    Wise and intelligent people out there, pls support the cause.
    We are in control of our own destiny.
    If a marriage do not work, find a solution rather than suffer the rest of our lives bringing in the family to suffer too. We do not believe we are that stupid, unless we are born one, which we are not.

    Comment by Stephen Tang — February 2, 2010 @ 12:14 PM | Reply

  4. Don’t be a fool & jump ship into PKR or any other peninsular based party. Anuar Ibrahim was part of the problems faced by Sabah today. This is what Sabah & Sarawak should do:

    1. The responsible (leaders of) parties in Sabah & Sarawak must come together & form a Common Third Front.
    2. With your MP’s acting as an independent BLOCK, anyone who wants to form a government at the Federal
    level at Putrajaya will need your support to form a government.
    3. Support them and participate at the Federal level at YOUR TERMS.
    4. Take full control of the State (Sabah & Sarawak) matters & you can solve all your local problems
    without interference from the Federal Government.
    5. Take care of yourselves (Sabah & Sarawak) NOW and you may be indirectly helping Peninsular Malaysia
    or West Malaysia (Malaya) ‘to get up and walk straight again’.
    6. Its time to change the wardrobe?????


    Comment by svmbanu — February 2, 2010 @ 1:04 AM | Reply

    • Yes, I do agree with a Third Front because I don’t think PKR will do both S&S much good.

      Comment by dee — February 2, 2010 @ 6:39 AM | Reply

    • # 3. Support them and participate at the Federal level at YOUR TERMS.#

      – Yesssss, spot on!

      Comment by Jong — February 2, 2010 @ 11:10 AM | Reply

    • Unfortunately there are very few “responsible” leaders from Sabah and Sarawak. Baru Bian and a few others might qualify.

      But vote for Jeffrey Kitingan and Taib Mahmud joining forces to be kingmakers as a “Third Force”? That would only accelerate the decline of Sarawak and Sabah’s institutions and democratic hopes.

      The crucial question is not whether we vote for Anwar, or for Najib. We have to choose between more of the same, totalitarian corruption, or a brighter future of a two-party system, where ALL Malaysians can call the shots, not just Taib and Jeffrey Kitingan or Musa Aman.

      Musa Aman and Taib and Jeffrey Kitingan belong to the obsolete past of political patronage. Let’s look forward to being able to wield influence through a two party democratic system.

      Comment by Pak Bui — February 2, 2010 @ 4:59 PM | Reply

    • Hey thanks for the visit, little UMNO cybertrooper! Hidup UMNO! parailah kitai…

      Comment by hornbillunleashed — February 2, 2010 @ 5:09 PM | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: