Hornbill Unleashed

November 4, 2010

Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family

By Keruah Usit

The company records for Quality Concrete, the timber licence holder at the centre of a land dispute that has led to mass protests, shows how ‘the politics of development’ work in Sarawak.

Quality Concrete Sdn Bhd, a company with interests in logging, construction, pipes, cement and plastic bags, has RM57.96 million in paid-up shares, according to information made public by the Companies Commission of Malaysia. A third of the shares are assigned to nominee companies, likely to be proxies.

raziah mahmudRaziah @ Rodiah Mahmud (left), younger sister to the Chief Minister Taib Mahmud, is a shareholder in the company. Together with a Mr Tiang Ming Sing, 59, she has been a director since January 2000. These two have been company directors longer than any of the other members of the board.

Another shareholder is Abdul Hamed Sepawi, Taib’s cousin. Hamed became chairman and a prominent shareholder in Sarawak Energy, after the state energy monopoly was sold off by the state government in 2005. He spearheads the drive to build 12 new hydro-electric dams in Sarawak, although the state already has a large surplus in electricity supply.

Hamed is also chairman of Naim Cendera, a conglomerate with interests, among others, in building dams, and Ta Ann, a gigantic logging company. Forbes has placed him as 39th among ‘Malaysia’s Richest’.

Two contrasting sets of community leaders

Tuai Rumah Numpang Suntai was one of seven Iban community leaders from upper Sebangan remanded on Oct 22, following an allegation by the logging contractor Loyal Billion, implicating them in arson at the company’s timber camp. The seven leaders were released on police bail on Oct 25 and have not been charged with any crime.

NONEOn Nov 1, Numpang Suntai (right) was also the leader among 14 plaintiffs, accompanied by a huge delegation sent by 15 Sebangan longhouses to the Kuching High Court to file a suit against Quality Concrete and Loyal Billion, and also against the state government and two local community leaders, Penghulu Merum Baru, 55, and Tua Kampung Agu Kaleng, 56.

The two government-appointed figureheads had signed, together with five other villagers from the area, a dubious ‘contract’ with Loyal Billion, purportedly on behalf of all the local villages.

The ‘contract’ was for “the purpose of hiring land and buying timber belonging to the villagers.” According to the ‘contract’, the company promised a ‘one-off compensation’ payment of RM800 to each Tua Kampung and RM250 to each pintu or family. These were miniscule sums compared to the loggers’ RM230 million windfall projected from the 3,305 hectares apportioned in the timber licence.

The plaintiffs rejected the ‘contract’ and ‘compensation’. Villagers speculate the company might have offered a much larger pay-out to the Penghulu and Tua Kampung, now named as co-defendants for the intrusion on the natives’ communal land.

As lead plaintiff, Numpang Suntai spoke up for the villagers at the High Court. “These are all the people whose land has been raped, whose land has been encroached, whose fruit trees have been destroyed,” he said, gesturing to 100 Iban villagers who had travelled from Sebuyau to Kuching to show support for the lawsuit.

“This injustice has to stop, and that’s why we are here… how about the lives of these people? It’s not only from the point of view of not being able to cultivate (crops). They cannot do any more hunting, they cannot do any more fishing. I don’t know how they are going to survive.

“Within this NCR land, there is timber which has been intentionally left by our forefathers for our future use…this has been cut (down),” he said.

Lawsuit the ‘tip of the iceberg’

NCR land is protected by law, and supported by legal precedents in the Federal Court. However, Taib’s government disregards these customary safeguards (adat) and past court decisions. Taib, wearing his hat as minister for resource planning, continues to issue logging licences, and establish oil palm estates, on land claimed under NCR by Iban and other native communities, throughout the state.

There are more than 200 lawsuits against the state government in the courts, filed by different ethnic groups, including Malays, Ibans, Penans and Bidayuhs. Half of these cases, including the Sebangan lawsuit, have been taken on, against considerable odds, by a single law firm, Baru Bian & Co.

NONE“This is a very important case for us and for the people that we represent,” Baru Bian (left), state PKR chairman, told the press at the courthouse, with the Sebangan supporters standing behind him.

“We found out in our investigations, that these so-called timber licensees were going or encroaching into native customary land, trying to get to the licensed area given to them. In the process of going into the area, they built logging roads, and at the same time they were felling and extracting timber along the road – but these are not licensed areas, so they are trespassing, encroaching, on native customary land.

“This is not the first case, I want to emphasise that. This is just the tip of the iceberg in Sarawak, and in our experience dealing with native customary rights (NCR) cases, these have been ongoing, from Lundu to Lawas,” he stressed.

Baru Bian pointed out the villagers had made numerous reports to the local authorities including the Resident, the police, and even to Suhakam. But their appeals were ignored. They concluded that no-one was listening, and began a blockade across the timber road last month.

“It boils down to the policies of the present government. And the people in authority are not bothered with the rights of the (ordinary) people,” he added. “We are talking about native rights, the indigenous rights of Sarawak, which are supposed to be protected by the government of the day, with a special provision in the laws of Malaysia.”

Taib has not commented on his links with the loggers or the police action against the Iban villagers. But it is becoming increasingly difficult for Taib to argue for his ‘politics of development’, when the most obvious ‘development’ seems to be directed at a small coterie of family and friends.

KERUAH USIT is a human rights activist – ‘anak Sarawak, bangsa Malaysia’. This weekly column is an effort to provide a voice for marginalised Malaysians. Keruah Usit can be contacted at keruah_usit@yahoo.com.

Advertisements

12 Comments »

  1. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by “Together, we safeguard our NCR land from land grab” « Hornbill Unleashed — March 10, 2011 @ 3:37 PM | Reply

  2. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by Interim injunction granted against Taib-linked companies | MoCS — March 7, 2011 @ 1:40 PM | Reply

  3. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by Interim Injunction granted against Taib-linked Companies « Hornbill Unleashed — March 7, 2011 @ 11:11 AM | Reply

  4. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by Why is Numpang Suntai charged for Criminal Intimidation ? « Hornbill Unleashed — February 17, 2011 @ 8:58 AM | Reply

  5. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by Solidarity with Mr Numpang Suntai « Hornbill Unleashed — February 16, 2011 @ 2:46 PM | Reply

  6. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by Court orders halt to logging by Taib-linked firms « Hornbill Unleashed — January 27, 2011 @ 12:01 PM | Reply

  7. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by NCR Defender to be charged in Court tomorrow « "Mangkang Menua,Mangkang Dunya,Ngetan Ke Bansa!!" — December 15, 2010 @ 4:15 AM | Reply

  8. […] Logging paper-trail leads to Taib’s family […]

    Pingback by NCR Defender to be charged in Court tomorrow « Hornbill Unleashed — December 14, 2010 @ 1:39 PM | Reply

  9. What other business does not lead to Taib Mahmud. Even our shit lead to him. I hope that with BN’s victories in both Galas and Batu Sapi bey- elections, Taib will be inspired to dissolve the DUN tomorrow morning (October 06 2010), to pave the way for Sarawak’s 10th state election.

    Comment by Mata kuching — November 4, 2010 @ 10:10 PM | Reply

  10. As the Romans were fond of saying, “All roads lead to Rome”.

    Comment by Poorpekmoh — November 4, 2010 @ 1:18 PM | Reply

  11. It is good to note “Robbing” as adopted by the government in their form of speech. This context has had been regularly outbursted by the our poor fellow citizens and hopefully it comes to realization beginning in a small manner. The greatest obstacle now is how to overcome the issue of land deprivations. Will there be an automatic rescind and a reversal to all the various sections of the Land Code that were amended hastily and indiscriminately during the reigns of Capt Demon Ring & The gang back to its original text. Many loopholes had already been created in order to mass acquiring the land that are claimed under native customary rights. These many amendments are so confusing until the Land Code Book now becoming like a bomoh manuscript. The original Sarawak Land Code though were precisely drafted by the Whites it gives in futuristic impact on protectionism over the indigenous groups so that they may continue to carry on and enjoy a total privileges over their inherited land until the many generations to come. If there is no provisions to reinstate back the original Land Code the masquerade to tame the poor kampong folks is just a mere temporary measure in the election fever.

    Comment by Miaowkia — November 4, 2010 @ 1:01 PM | Reply

  12. WHAT VALUE FOR NCR TIMBER?

    “The ‘contract’ was for “the purpose of hiring land and buying timber belonging to the villagers.” According to the ‘contract’, the company promised a ‘one-off compensation’ payment of RM800 to each Tua Kampung and RM250 to each pintu or family. These were miniscule sums compared to the loggers’ RM230 million windfall projected from the 3,305 hectares apportioned in the timber licence”

    The question and answer as to what claim should be made against Quality Concrete is very straight forward – $230 million.

    No need to argue as this is the estimated worth of the timber alone not including land. Add on value of land.

    But then NCR land with its timber should not be negotiable at any cost and should be preserved for the landowners and all of us to enjoy.

    Further to negotiate any amount is to acknowledge the legality of the land grab and licence issued. This should never be done.

    Comment by Abang — November 4, 2010 @ 8:49 AM | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: