Hornbill Unleashed

October 6, 2011

Changing the world, one film at a time

Keruah Usit

The camerawork was admittedly shaky, but a short documentary called ‘Ulu Bengoh Darom Piin‘ (or ‘Upper Bengoh, underwater’ in one of the Bidayuh languages) that premiered at the Freedom Film Fest on Oct 2, was quite an eye-opener.

Joachim Leong, fresh from law school, recently led a team of young urban film-makers to four rural Bidayuh villages up in the mountains of Bengoh, Sarawak, 45 minutes’ drive from the cineplexes and Starbuckses of Kuching.

They were curious: why did many villagers in the area, forced to resettle by the Bengoh dam built last year, return the incumbent, Dr Jerip Susil, in the state election in April, despite losing their land to companies serving the BN?

Why did so many rural voters return BN to power, despite the rousing urban pro-Pakatan crowds?

NONEIn trying to explain the rural voters’ support for a BN government, slated for land grabs throughout Sarawak, Leong writes, in the blogLoyarburuk: “The rural-urban divide exists as a mental and physical barrier, with a host of reasons as to why such a barrier does exist.”

The film attempted to see beyond that chasm.

Endless broken promises

The film-makers captured images of the beauty of the mountains and the unique culture of the Bidayuh, as well as the hard grind of the villagers’ daily lives.

NONEThe team trekked up to the villages perched up on the high slopes, accessible only on foot.

They learned how only a handful of houses had small solar panels that lit up a single bulb for a few hours, so that some lucky schoolchildren might get to read, before the chorus of cicadas at bedtime.

The villagers told of endless broken promises by the BN state government. The authorities had insisted that the dam was needed to ensure future supplies of clean water to the city folk of Kuching, and had pledged compensation and modern facilities in a resettlement area.

The resettlement scheme remains a wasteland, as seen during filming in August.

The bare planks of the Bengoh villagers’ simple houses in their own relocation area upstream, were built by their own hands. There is no running water or electricity supply.

The film depicted these images as a dramatic counterpoint to the government’s narrative of the dam being a vital part of ‘development’.

NONEThere is a subplot, though this was not the focus of the film. The Bengoh dam contract went to a conglomerate, Naim, chaired by Hamed Sepawi (left), first cousin to Taib Mahmud, the Chief Minister. Taib is the minister in charge of natural resources – including dams.

Naim snagged the RM310 million contract without open competition, and “subbed” out the work to Sinohydro, a Chinese construction firm, for RM145 million – less than half of Naim’s windfall.

But there was no ‘win-win’ result for the villagers: they lost their land to the dam-builders. They were given little compensation, and even less say in their future.

One community, Kampung Semban, were astonished to find they were being driven out even though their houses lay above the water level of the dam.

Villagers have said Naim and its partners were simply grabbing land, using the dam as a pretext.

The villagers sued the government two years ago, but the courthouse is far away, and lawsuits take time.

The big picture

Ulu Bengoh Darom Piin’ explored the contradictions in the poverty of the area, and the government’s string of broken promises, with the thumping majority won by the BN.

NONEJerip Susil (right) won 8,093 votes to the PKR’s Willie Mongin’s 4,447. Two other candidates, one from SNAP and another independent, won some 2,000 votes.

Were there lessons to learn? The film gently, but humorously, pointed out that the PKR candidate, Willie Mongin, did not actually set foot in any of the four villages affected by the dam.

When the film-makers asked him why, he gave a series of bizarre answers, providing excuses to do with “strategy”, “time limitations” and “finances”, for not visiting the voters.

Selangor PKR executive councillor R Sivarasa and PKR national legal bureau chief Latheefa Koya were present in the audience, and showed the appropriate embarrassment, as well as concern that viable alternative candidates will have to be offered in future polls.

Another reason explored in the film was a mindset among some villagers that Dr Jerip had pledged to fight for their interests.

Some voters drew a distinction between the likeable person of the individual elected representative and his campaign promises on the one hand, with the BN-linked companies taking their land, on the other.

There are, of course, other reasons for the unexpected margin of the BN victory in April’s election, that the film did not address.

One is the widespread buying and manipulation of votes. Bersih 2.0 and Malaysian Election Observers (MEO-Net, an NGO that works on voter awareness in Sarawak) are striving hard on this front.

Another, more important, reason is that while the voters are kept poor, in order to limit their independence and access to information, the cause is not simply local corruption, but also the continuing economic deprivation of Sabah and Sarawak.

These are two of the poorest states in the federation, despite contributing vast amounts to the national coffers through Petronas.

This impoverishment means large numbers of rural voters remain uneducated. They are kept dependent on handouts and on the propaganda of the mainstream media.

Perhaps it will take more than one good documentary to bridge the ‘rural-urban divide’ that Leong writes of.

But it is a fine step in the right direction.

(‘Ulu Bengoh Darom Piin’ and the Freedom Film Fest is showing all over Malaysia, and I for one urge all readers to see these challenging films on offer. Entrance is free of charge.)

Some Snapshot and Screening Here :-

See Bengoh when it is still dry


KERUAH USIT is a human rights activist – ‘anak Sarawak, bangsa Malaysia’. This weekly column is an effort to provide a voice for marginalised Malaysians. Keruah Usit can be contacted a tkeruah_usit@yahoo.com

9 Comments »

  1. The lawyer doesn’t understand the way of life in the villages. She does not understand the culture of local people. She was supposed to get her visit permit from JKR, Tuai Kampung, District Office from that kawasan itself. Perhaps she meant well, but she created havoc for the innocent people. The poor villagers are not well educated in the formal sense. I guess, they thought that she went there to film a movie called “James Bond in Bengoh” or let me think “Clint Eastwood in Bengoh?”, for that reason they supported her. Is she really honest and keen to help the people there? Is it necessary for us to create havoc like what she did? That’s why the rural voters loved BN because the visitor like you guys came to them with shady objective.

    “I would rather try to persuade a man to go along, because once I have persuaded him, he will stick. If I scare him, he will stay just as long as he is scared, and then he is gone.”

    Dwight D. Eisenhower (1890-1969) Thirty-fourth President of the USA.

    Comment by Dilema Anak Pendatang — October 7, 2011 @ 4:07 PM | Reply

  2. In Sabah we have plenty supply of “New Malaysian”. From the official figures given, there are some 91,190 “new Malaysian” being given the MYcard (citizenships) in Sabah since January to June 2011. This figure is alarming and what is the reason that so many “new Malaysian” can be approved in such a short period. It is estimated around 125 new Malaysian being produced in Sabah everyday. How come these people mostly Pilipino and Indonesian can obtain the Malaysian citizenships?

    It is high time that we should put a stop to this outflow of our valued Malaysians who are going away and we should try to change the current situation in the country to attract the estimated 1.4 millions of Malaysian who are staying away from home. We must bring back those who had left, and it will be of much benefit to the country and its people. To grant citizenship status to foreigners in huge numbers will harm the country especially in Sabah.

    Comment by Kinabalu boy — October 7, 2011 @ 11:51 AM | Reply

    • you re complaining about new m’sian. Those who ran away most of them were unhappy citizens too. There’s no different at all.

      Comment by Dilema Anak Pendatang — October 8, 2011 @ 12:03 PM | Reply

  3. quote: They were curious: why did many villagers in the area, forced to resettle by the Bengoh dam built last year, return the incumbent, Dr Jerip Susil, in the state election in April, despite losing their land to companies serving the BN?

    answer: bn and jerip susil will use this extremely effective statement “if you vote for the opposition, the dap communist chinese will sweep to power and take EVERYTHING you have from your women, lands, rights, future and children. i know this because i’m married to a chinese and she has told me about the communist mindset”

    “it is better that taib takes away your land because it will be for development but if the communist chinese dap takes it, it will be for their personal gain and property”

    and this is why Bn will ALWAYS win in the next general and state elections

    Comment by mike — October 7, 2011 @ 9:12 AM | Reply

    • Then you should look and help chinese in China lo. Ask Wen what can he do to claim chinese rights.

      Comment by Dilema Anak Pendatang — October 7, 2011 @ 2:27 PM | Reply

      • Stupid racist and ignorant comment by this Dilletante. Another cheap BN cybergroupie.

        Comment by Analist — October 7, 2011 @ 7:15 PM | Reply

  4. Hi, it looks interested to me,
    but how am i able to get it?

    Please pm me through my email, khengboon13@hotmail.com

    much more appreciate…

    Comment by Liaw Kheng Boon — October 6, 2011 @ 7:34 AM | Reply

    • Saturday – 8th October at Pusat Rakyat LB, Bangsar Utama – Those Damned Dams!

      A Screening of Sarawakian Dam-related short films.

      Programme:

      7.45-8.00 – Arrival, Chat with Sarawakian Activists

      8.00-8.30 – Screening of Ulu Bengoh Darom Piin

      8.30-8.50 – Discussion on Film and Chat with Crew

      8.50-9.30 – Screening of Bakun Dam Documentary by Chou Z Lam Pt.1

      9.30- 10.00 – Discussion on Film and Chat with Affected Villagers in Baram.

      Lastly , keep the conversation going on twitter #Bengoh Let’s make it synonymous with the urban-rural divide debate in Malaysia.

      Comment by Hornbill Unleashed — October 6, 2011 @ 7:58 AM | Reply

  5. […] 5, 2011 by democracy4now Changing the world, one film at a time — Hornbill Unleashed @ 12:03 […]

    Pingback by Malaysiakini’s review of Bengoh film: highly recommended viewing! « Sarawak Indigenous Community News — October 6, 2011 @ 12:29 AM | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: