Hornbill Unleashed

March 14, 2012

Helping His Constituents Or Helping Himself? Billy Abit Joo

Sarawak Report

Najib hands a mock RM5Million cheque for the Bakun Resettlement Committee to PRS boss Masing and MP Billy Abit Joo just before the state election – but did the locals see any of that money?

The Federal MP for Hulu Rejang, Bakun says that he “wants to keep serving his people” for another 5th term.  However, his rival Wilson Ugat, who is the political secretary to their PRS party chief, BN’s James Masing, says he “wants a turn”.

We ask whether these men are squabbling for the chance to help their people or to grab more wealth and resources from Bakun and elsewhere?

After all, during the 22 years that Billy Abit Joo has held his seat 10,000 of his constituents have been driven from their lands to make way for the Bakun Dam. He supported this project, but what benefit have the people received from the logging and flooding of their lands?

Sucking up to Taib and Najib and receiving the benefits – but what has Billy Abit Joo done to help his people

It is now a decade since they were pushed from their homes, yet most of these refugees have yet to receive more than a fraction of the compensation they were promised.

They have now even been told they have to pay for their replacement homes out of the compensation money, which they have yet to fully receive, putting them supposedly ‘in debt’ to the state!

So, what happened to BN’s original promises of free new homes, free water and electricity, new jobs and of course handsome compensation on top?

And what happened to the billions of ringgit that were made out of the logging of these lands by Ekran, a company owned by Taib crony Ting Pek Kiing and Taib’s own sons?

We have to ask, in 22 years what use has Billy Abit Joo been in getting just compensation for his constituents in these matters?

Billy Abit Joo’s flooded constituents

Wargana Consortium Sdn Bhd

Man to trust? – Taib henchman Awang Tenggah called Wargana Consortium “a company owned by the people themselves”!

Wargana Consortium Sdn Bhd is an enterprise that perfectly spells out the difference between what Billy Abit Joo promises and what he actually does. It shows how, while he promises to enrich his people, he is actually working to enrich himself and key supporters.

Wargana Consortium was announced back in 2010 as a cooperative enterprise. Taib side-kick and sub-Minister for Planning and Resources, Awang Tenggah, called it:

“a company formed by the people themselves”[Borneo Post].

Billy Abit Joo then described a RM 9.8million contract awarded by Sarawak Hydro to clear 60,000 tons of dangerous debris in the Bakun Dam area as some kind of shared venture:

“The local people hold 50 per cent of the share and the other 50 belongs to Wargana Consortium Sdn Bhd”, he claimed. [Borneo Post again]

Billy also said that local people would get the opportunity to work on the venture and provide their own boats to the project to help clear up the waters.

Vote buying! – BN’s Billy Abit Joo tries to pretend that these vouchers paid for by public money are a gift from BN to poor people. Part of the disastrous BR1M hand out last month, where so many of the poorest people failed in the end to get their cash.

These statements gave the clear impression that the project was offering work and also that a 50% share of the profit from the RM9.8million contract would go in dividends to the local people.

If this were really the case you might praise a local MP for arranging such help for his people.However, the promises over the Wargana Consortium have turned out to be as thin as those over compensation for Bakun.


Firstly, our researches show that there is no shared venture. The whole debris-clearing project was awarded to Wargana Consortium Sdn Bhd alone, according to Sarawak Hydro’s own web announcement. There is no record at all of 50% of the share going to local people!

Project was awarded 100% to Wargana Consortium – no 50% to the ‘local people’

As one local resident of the resettlement area of Sungai Asap explains, “The contract is totally controlled by Wargana. They have hired around 20 local workers, that is all”.

So, who owns Wargana Consortium? Is it that there has there been some confusion and that Wargana itself is 50% owned by the local people?

If this was the case then the local people should all be registered as shareholders in the company and they should be expecting to receive not only jobs in the clearing project, but also a 50% share of the company profits.

True ownership of Wargana Consortium

Sadly, this is far from the case.  In a disgraceful conflict of interest, Wargana Consortium is in fact controlled by none other than than the local MP, our familiar friend Billy Abit Joo!

His three fellow Directors are the businessman David Wong, Alice Sia (who is the daughter  of the BN crony businessman Datuk Sia Hong Ngee) and another prominent local BN politician, the former State Assemblyman Nyipa Batok.  Nyipa Batok just happens to also be the father in law of Billy’s PRS leader, James Masing. As we have previously exposed,  Corinne Nyipa Masing is also the shareholder of numerous companies that have received state contracts.

Not just a local MP, but the local businessman receiving the top public contract for the Bakun area!

So, if these political types are in charge of this publicly funded project, who do we think are the shareholders of the company?

Well it turns out that these four Directors are the main shareholders of just under two thirds of the enterprise, through two of the three companies that make up Wargana Consortium, which are Wargana Management Sdn Bhd and Sinaran Bakun Sdn Bhd.

Billy Abit Joo is one of the key Directors of Wargana Consortium and he is also a major shareholder through the company Sinaran Bakun Sdn Bhd. The other shareholder is the Dad of James Masing’s wife, Nyipa Batok!

So, what about the supposed 50% share that is meant to be going to the ‘local people’?  Well, it simply isn’t true. Instead, we have discovered that a very typical BN style of profit sharing has been underway!

It turns out that the remaining third of Wargana Consortium has been handed to a supposedly ‘public’ company called Sinaran Bakun (M) Bhd.  This is a very unusual public company, because it has only issued 26 shares and they are certainly not being traded on the stock exchange.

Only one third of Wargana Consortium is shared with Sinaran Bakun (M) bhd in which each head man has a share. However Billy Abit Joo has two shares along with Corinne Masing’s Dad – and it is they who control the company as the Directors!

And who has been given those shares?  The lucky list of shareholders are none other than 24 key local headmen in the Sungai Asap longhouses. These are the people whom BN pay to be the ‘representatives’ of their people – the people who will be hoping to ‘advise’ their longhouse folk on whom they should vote for at the coming election!

Normally BN like to hand out bribes just to top cronies. But at Bakun have the incentives had to spread a little further to keep local leaders happy in the face of so many broken promises?

It should be noted that Billy and Nyipa Batok are also in this list of shareholders too and they have twice as many shares as the others!  And guess who are the Directors of this company, Sinaran Bakun (M) Bhd?  The same key three people who manage Wargana Consortium and the other shareholder companies, of course!  Billy Abit Joo, Nyipa Batok and businessman David Wong!

The headmen may be the shareholders, but they have no control over the company.

No money for the people

Since these three men are in control of the Consortium itself and are the main Directors of the three shareholding companies, as well as being the owners of by far the greatest number of shares, then it is these three men who are in a position to determine the size of the profits, the expenditures of the company, the pay for Directors and everything else for this “company owned by the people themselves”.

“We knew the headmen had been given a sort of representative share for each of the longhouses” explained the Sungai Asap resident.  ”But it was never explained how any of the money would come down to us and it hasn’t!”

So what did Billy Abit Joo and ex-assemblyman Nyipa Batok by claiming that 50% of the profits would come to the local people?  Why did Awang Tenggah claim that the consortium was “formed by the people themselves”?

And how did these politicians come to be in possession of such a large number of shares in this consortium, which has been corruptly handed such a large contract by Sarawak Hydro, in what is a clear conflict of interest?


A RM9.8Million job not done – the debris is being hidden not burnt!

Meanwhile, we have discovered a great deal about the reality of this major debris clearing contract and the situation regarding those profits, which were supposed to go to the local people.

Our enquiries show that so far not only have the local people to see a single ringgit, but the headmen shareholders have not received money either.

We have been told that there have been arguments over the failure of Wargana Consortium to provide the promised dividends between the managers and the company and the headmen.

We can reveal that the outcome of this situation has proved a major scandal, provoking illegal logging and a dangerous situation whereby millions of ringgit of public money have been paid out to clear debris, which has ended up hidden rather than being burnt!

According to our inside sources, Wargana company bosses placated the angry headmen by signalling that they would turn a blind eye to logging in the Bakun reservoir area, which is meant to be managed and controlled by the consortium.

“The company is supposed to deal with debris within a 15kilometer radius of the dam. However, they are allowing some of the headmen to bring in workers from Bintulu, who are then logging on the hillsides beyond that radius.  Only a few of them have got involved, but they have made a lot of money” explained our source. “The illegal loggers take the timber to Samling who are the nearby concession holders, who have paid them a great deal for this valuable hill top wood!”

Deadly pile ups of logs and debris are being hidden around Bakun’s vast lake by contract workers who have no incinerator to use!

Just last year this scandal of illegal logging was publicly condemned by none other thanAwang Tenggah.  Yet it turns out that the whole scandal was promoted and condoned by the company of the local MP, Billy Abit Joo!

In typical BN style they have corrupted the local leaders to control the anger and rebellion from the longhouses.

But neither, it turns out, has Wargana Consortium being doing the job it is supposed to do.   Most of the work is sub-contracted to small outfits, according to our informants from the area.

“Wargana Consortium was supposed to build an incinerator to burn this wood, but they have not.  So they are just allowing other small outfits to deal with the wood and again they are turning a blind eye.  Those small contractors have just been hiding the wood in secret places around the lake!”, confided one local person who has provided us with photographs of some of those hidden mounds of debris

RM9.8Million has gone to Wargana Consortium to clear the debris from the lake – but it seems to be public money that has been wasted!

So, this is the job that the Directors of Wargana Consortium, led by the local MP Billy Abit Joo, have carried out in return for all that public money!

They have allowed the logs to be hidden round the Bakun lake, instead of building an incinerator and they have turned a blind eye to illegal logging to avoid paying the local people their rightful share of the profits!

Sarawak Report rests its case when it says that the story of Wargana Consortium sums up perfectly the difference between what BN politician practice and what BN politicians preach!

How MP and Company Director Billy Abit Joo took RM9.8Million of public money and didn’t do the job!

They know what is right, however they do what is wrong and it is their constituents that suffer!

But this is not the only activity that involves Wargana Consortium Sdn Bhd.

Timber contracts too!

It turns out that Wargana Corporation has been going far longer than the debris-clearance contract and the supposed profit sharing venture with the people in Billy Abit Joo’s constituency.

Wargana Consortium was set up in 2005 and has a huge swathe of timber concessions as well!  According to our copy of the Forestry Department’s maps, thousands of hectares have been given over to the company controlled by MP Billy Abit Joo and his fellow BN crony shareholders.

Yet there is no evidence that any of the local people of Sungai Asap were aware of this asset or that they have received any of the profits from their shareholding.

Timber concessions worth tens of millions of ringgit. Did the local people of Bakun gain any share in these profits? Did the Headmen with shares get any share of these profits?

Now that they can see how much their MP Billy Abit Joo and his cronies are making from logging, it is perhaps easier for the people of Bakun to understand why it is that he and so many of their local leaders, like James Masing’s father in law, Nyipa Batok have been telling them to keep on voting BN and to be patient about the destruction of their lands !

They can perhaps now see how Taib has been bribing a few BN political leaders the at the expense of the rest of the people of Sarawak!

The area of Wargama Consortium’s timber concessions

Wilson Ugat

The people of Bakun might conclude that they should, therefore, replace the long-term liar and plunderer Billy Abit Joo with his PRS rival Wilson Ugat, who is the close supporter of their party boss, James Masing.

Sucking up to the big boss – PRS leader has done well out of making sure his party supports BN, because Taib has allowed him to cheat his own people

However, we should remind readers of our other recent expose, showing how Ugat and James Masing conspired together with Sri Aman Assemblyman Mong Dagang to make RM 70 million in kickbacks out of NCR land which they had confiscated for plantations!

We have published the letter signed by Mong asking for the money to be paid into a company which is owned by Masing’s brother, Mong’s wife and Wilson Ugat’s wife, Leyta Kupa! [see the story]

So what advantage is there to voting for another corrupted PRS member of BN, who promises one thing, but does quite another?



  1. I am a recipient of the Bakun Trust Fund..without it i could not have completed my studies and earned my degree..why dont you post all the number of graduates from sungai asap who have benefited from bakun trust fund…regarding wargana although i agree that they should be less fooochow involvement it must be said that they employ many of our people on site and earnings were distributed to longhouse heads although how each individual longhouse disbursed the money to their people was up to their leaders,… anyway why dont you snoop up on James Masing , Datin Maria and his crony Wilson Ugak ,instead his laundry list is far more interesting if you got the ballls to do it

    Comment by frcyt — April 25, 2012 @ 12:55 AM | Reply

  2. Bakun people are too dumb to understand what is going around them…..look life getting tougher day by day to the Bakun people and still they vote for BN wih majority!

    Comment by Rod — March 16, 2012 @ 2:00 AM | Reply

  3. The Bakun Resettlement Committee must either confirm or deny receiving the RM5million from the BN government. Where is the money? Lodge a police report for CBT if the money has yet to be deposited in the bank account held in trust by the Bakun Resettlement Committee.

    Comment by Mata Kuching — March 15, 2012 @ 11:45 PM | Reply

  4. NCR rebellions against corporate invaders among Sarawak’s 1.4 million Dayaks could shift the political balance in Malaysia. Dayaks, regardless of their political affiliation, must stand united to liberate themselves of the UMNO controlled BN’s colonisation and enslavement of their minds and economic assets. All the arrogant and self indulged towkays in BN must be kicked out.

    How so very often the rural Dayaks were warned by Dayak leaders like Alfred Jabu, James Masing, William Mawan, Michael Manyin, Richard Riot, Mong Dagang, Peter Nansian and all self serving YBs not to welcome the ” trouble making” Pakatan leaders and campaigners into their longhouse and kampung. We can see that they had been and were very afraid that all these “political” concessions, projects and contracts awarded to them and family by the thief minister shall be exposed.by Pakatan comprising DAP, PAS and PKR. It is now an open secret that Dayak leaders in BN had been cheating their own community and pawning their future to keep the thief minister Taib Mahmud stay in power till he dies.

    All concerned Sarawakians, NGOs, NCR landowners and the Dayak community must march to the thief minister office to tell him to stop stealing, looting and plundering and to stop all future dams construction.

    To save Sarawak and to prevent the Dayaks from becoming aliens in their own ancestral and NCR land, we must say NO to UMNO controlled BN government and the thief minister of Sarawak Taib Mahmud in GE13 and the next state election.

    Comment by Mata Kuching — March 15, 2012 @ 10:27 PM | Reply

  5. Sarawak Report together with Pakatan Rakyat and Civil Societies, should do a documentary with compilations of all these facts and documents and let the voters in each constituency know how corrupted their BN YBs are and what a big liar they have been. Distribute all the documentary in CDs to all the rural constituencies.

    Comment by Alex — March 14, 2012 @ 8:32 PM | Reply

  6. It’s time for James Masing/Billy/PRS to seek forgiveness from jungle spirits…

    For best result never use cheap grade pork and cheap langkau

    Instead offer Kobe Beef meat (RM5,000 per kg) and crates of Remy Martin Louis XIII X.O. costs RM9,000 each bottle

    Whether the jungle spirits forgive him for cheating made fools of Dayak well let hope for the best lah

    Muja Menua… appeasing the angry gods
    By Peter Sibon, The Borneo Post, Sunday 5 December 2010

    IN 1924 a Muja Menua miring ceremony was held to mark the end of hostilities between the Kayans and Kenyahs and the Ibans in the upper reaches of the Rajang.

    The hostilities was a result of the tribes literally colliding into each other as the Kayans and Kenyahs move downstream from the headwaters of the Rejang and Baleh towards Kapit while the Ibans spread upstream from Kapit.

    The peace treaty was brokered by one of the more colourful officers of the Brooke reign, Gerald MacBryan and cleverly enforced by the holding of the Muja Menua miring in November that year.

    In the Iban tradition the Muja Menua is the highest level of miring, the ceremonial prayers and rituals to appease the spirits and gods for sins committed against humanity and nature.

    Such is the level of Muja Menua that it was never held again until this year and coincidentally also in the month of November and in the upper reaches of the same river — the Rajang.

    However, the Muja Menua held on Nov 17 this year was not to cement a peace treaty but to seek forgiveness and appease the gods for the ravages wreaked on the environment by the people through logging and other activities.

    Apparently the devastation of the environment in the headwaters areas of the Baleh which is a tributary of the Rajang had so angered the spirits of the forests and mountains that they brought on massive landslides that caused logs, branches and other debris tumbling into the river resulting in the most massive logjam ever seen in Sarawak.

    On Oct 17 the people living along the Baleh and Rejang were flabbergasted by the sight the mighty rivers choked a solid mass of logs, trees and branches floating down stream like Nabau the Iban mythical serpent — some estimated the logjam to be 250 kilometres long.

    Although the cost of the physical damages caused by the floating logs was small, the environmental damage was massive and unlikely to be fully gauged. Fish, prawns and other aquatic life in the rivers were suffocated by the silt and mud churned up by the logs.

    Although the river folk had a field day picking up dying fish and prawns in the river, their hearts were filled with misgivings and fear for the future.

    The Ibans in Baleh have expressed their fear and believed that the reason behind the massive debris along the Baleh/Rejang Rivers was the wrath of the gods who were angry with the loggers as the tractors and bulldozers have damaged their abode at Ulu Sg Melatai.

    For some, they believed that the indiscriminate pollution at the domains of the spirits of the rivers, jungles and mountains at Ulu Sg Melatai have caused the gods to move out from their domains and caused the massive movement that resulted in the massive debris being washed down the rivers.

    During a meeting with 12 Iban village chiefs held at Rumah Tujai, Ng Sebiro, Entawau, Baleh on Oct12, they have told Dato Sri Dr James Masing, the Minister of Land Development that a grand miring ceremony must be held to appease the spirits as soon as possible.

    Masing had said then that he would have to discuss the matter with the Majlis Adat Istiadat the kind of miring ceremony that would be most appropriate to appease the deities, and more so, the wrath of the local people.

    “The ceremony will hopefully appease the gods as well as the local people. At this stage, they only blamed the loggers but we must stopped their anger otherwise they vent it out at the government.

    “My top priority now is not only to appease the people but also the gods whose wraths could worsen the already tense situation,” Masing told thesundaypost after meeting.

    For the Ibans in Baleh their wrath was justified as their livelihood had been devastated by the logjam causing a complete lost of fish and animals from their jungles which they claimed as their ‘supermarket’.

    “But we are very angry with the loggers because the ‘Baleh Tsunami’ or logjam is caused by them. They have made the abode of the gods too noisy with their tractors and other heavy machineries which made the gods to get angry and shake the forest and resulted in the devastation,” said Tuai Rumah Sebaung, Ng Melamah, Baleh.

    They said the disrespectful ways of the loggers to nature have created an enmity between them and the local people.

    Masing, himself a Christian, who earned his PhD in anthropology through his research on Iban studies stressed that the miring ceremony was not against the Christian teachings as it is part and parcel of the Iban’s culture and tradition.

    “Miring is part of the socio-religious fabric of the Iban community. So there is no reason to think that the miring ceremony is diminishing among the community,” stressed Masing.

    It was determined the landslides occurred at Ulu Sg. Malatai, which is a tributary of the Baleh.

    Masing brushes off talk of angry gods
    Borneo Post August 5, 2011, Friday

    KUCHING: Land Development Minister Tan Sri Dr James Masing yesterday urged people not to believe that recent deaths reported in the Bakun area were due to the wrath of angry gods and unappeased spirits.

    Masing who was met after chairing a meeting at his office at Bangunan Baitulmakmur here yesterday told reporters that he was disappointed that the issue was blown out of proportion.

    “The State Health Department had confirmed that the deaths were due to melioidosis and leptospirosis and should not any way be linked to any spiritual belief.

    “I believe that many of the Orang Ulu in the area are educated and should not believe the story,” said Masing.

    He pointed out that the State Health Department was doing its best to prevent the disease from spreading and affecting others in the area.

    The Borneo Post yesterday quoted Bakun Community Safety Committee (BCSC) chairman Dr Elli Luhat as saying the deaths
    were caused by angry spirits in the area because they could not hold any rituals to appease their ancestors whose graves had been submerged under water.

    Elli added that it was because the people did not have the fund to do so as they had not received compensation for their relocation and submersion of the cemeteries.

    Comment by Teddy Gumbang — March 14, 2012 @ 4:29 PM | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: