Hornbill Unleashed

October 28, 2012

‘Documents show BN okayed controversial condo’

Koh Jun Linprotest at batu cave temple 261012 condo drawing

During a visit to the site for the condominium’s construction, Selangor exco member for local government Ronnie Liu brought with him the building plans approved by the BN-era Selanyang Municipal Council (MPS) on Nov 29, 2007.It was the BN and not Pakatan Rakyat that approved the controversial condominium project near the Batu Caves temple, and this time the Selangor government has the documents to prove it.

“It says very clearly that the development is a 29-storey service apartment, a 25-storey service apartment, and in front are shophouses that have already been built…

“Nobody, including the temple committee chairperson, should put the blame on Pakatan Rakyat because this was clearly done by the BN. It’s all there – chopped, signed, everything,” he said.

protest at batu cave temple 261012 former selayang counsellor a kohilan pillayThe plans included architectural drawings of the tower block that the nearby Sri Subramaniar Temple committee members yesterdaycomplained would obstruct view of the iconic limestone hill where it is situated.

Yesterday former Selanyang Municipal councillor and present deputy foreign minister A Kohilan Pillay (right) blamed the Pakatan government for the project, claiming that what had been approved in 2007 was only a “planning permit” that did not specify the number of storeys.

“Nothing was done by the Pakatan Rakyat government to support the project,” said Liu.

Kohilan is ‘bullshitting’

As for Kohilan’s claim that only the planning permit was approved during his tenure and not the building permit, Liu dismissed it as nonsense.

“There is no such thing as ‘kelulusan pelaksanaan’ (execution permit). He is bullshitting, naive or acting stupid. The ‘kelulusan perancangan’ (planning permit) is an overall (permit) already,” he said.

When asked about the marketing permit mentioned by Kohilan to have been approved in July this year, Liu said this falls under the jurisdiction of the federal government’s Housing Ministry.

He said the Pakatan-led government had also approved alterations to the surrounding roads and drainages, but this has no bearing on the controversial condominium itself.

Liu revealed that Pakatan leaders including DAP advisor Lim Kit Siang had met the temple committee and visited the condominium’s construction site on Monday.

Following this, the Selangor government had issued a stop-work order the following day and the MPS president has been told to refer the matter to the State Planning Committee (SPC) for review.

Batu caves condo near temple site of project

“Why? Because we are also interested in protecting our national heritage,” he said.

Liu also claimed that the temple committee chairperson R Nadarajah had promised to call off his protestat the time, but nevertheless went ahead with his plans yesterday.

He added that the review would take about a month.

When asked if it would meet Nadarajah’s one-month deadline before he takes legal action, Liu said he was not concerned with the ultimatum because the stop-work order is indefinite and will remain until the matter is resolved.

No EIA done

Liu declined to speculate on the sum needed to compensate the developer, Dolomite Industries Sdn Bhd, if the state government decides to scrap the project.

Batu caves condo near temple m manoharan from dap

However, he said that the state would not have to pay if the project breached any building guidelines, including whether it is sufficiently far enough from the nearby limestone cliffs and overhang.

Liu confirmed the claim by Malaysian Nature Society that no environmental impact assessment was done for the project. He, however, said it was not compulsory for projects of this scale.

“If it is not of a certain size, it becomes discretionary. In this case, I think it is necessary, because it is so close to the limestone hills and so close to a national heritage site,” he said.

According to Lim, the state government did not take action earlier because there had been no complaints over the tower block until recently.

Meanwhile, Kota Alam Shah assemblyperson M Manoharan (right) said Nadarajah should step down for being ignorant of the project although the condominium’s sales office is only a short distance down the road from the temple.

He also claimed that there is a Supreme Court order made in 1930 that the temple could not sue or be sued without the attorney-general’s consent, and he wants it abolished.

“It is high time for this order to be set aside,” he said, adding that the order is outdated.

4 Comments »

  1. The Umno-BN had shitted here,there and everywhere for many,many years in the country!This is only the tip of the mountains of shit that they have had shitted!The filty shit-heads even have the shitty gall by stirring and shifting their shits towards others!Total Umno-BN shits!

    Comment by Reapusow — October 28, 2012 @ 8:36 AM | Reply

  2. Obviously someone (politic ?) is playing dirty by provocation !!! Think ! You know, I know !!!

    Comment by teres6842550 — October 28, 2012 @ 2:24 AM | Reply

  3. Time for a call to malaysians of hindu origin,we should stand together in getting this project cancelled if it means the Temple committee has to pay the land owners the required damage.
    The Lord Murugan is all mighty and powerfull,whoEver who decides to go ahead will pay dearly for his act.
    only time will tell.
    Let th e Temple committee collect $10 per indian throughut the country and buy off the land.
    VEL MURUGA VEL MURUGA,VEL MURUGA

    Comment by BATU CAVES TO BE PRESERVED AT ALL COSTS — October 28, 2012 @ 12:44 AM | Reply

    • MY INDIAN FRIENDS, PLEASE CHECK IF SAMMY VELLU OR OTHER MIC CHIEF SUPPORTED AND TOGETHER WITH UMNO, DID APROVED THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE CONDO. SO CLOSE TO BATU CAVE, YET MIC DOES NOT KNOW ABOUT IT???????

      ALL MIC MEMBERS JUST VOTE FOR ABU…ABU…ANYBODY BUT UMNO/BN THIS GE13.

      Comment by Alfred gan — October 28, 2012 @ 4:47 PM | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: