Hornbill Unleashed

January 29, 2013

Hindraf losing steam, Indians likely back with BN, say analysts

Boo Su-Lyn

File photo of Hindraf leader P. Uthayakumar carried by supporters in Kuala Lumpur soon after his release from ISA detention in May 2009 for his part in the massive demonstration by the movement two years earlier.

Putrajaya’s decision to lift its ban on rights group Hindraf will not add to Barisan Nasional’s (BN) Indian support much, analysts have said, pointing out that the ruling pact already has most of the community’s vote in the bag.

In a strategically-timed move over the weekend, the Najib administration agreed to legalise the Hindu Rights Action Force, the movement that had led a massive anti-government protest in 2007 to demand for Indian rights.

The tumultuous event, which saw some 30,000 Indians marching down the streets of the capital under a shower of chemical water and plumes of tear gas, has been largely credited for BN’s apparent failure to snag the Indian vote in Election 2008.

But some five years on, analysts believe that Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak has come far in recapturing the community’s respect, thanks to his administration’s many conciliatory efforts, cash handouts and Indian outreach programmes.

“I don’t think it (lifting the ban) will have much effect,” political scientist Wong Chin Huat told The Malaysian Insider yesterday.

“I am inclined to believe that BN has succeeded in wooing back most of the Indian swing voters they can woo. A last-minute pre-election gesture is unlikely to swing the more critical ones of the swing voters,” he said.

Wong stressed, however, that 20 per cent of Indian voters are still fence-sitters, with BN and its political foes in Pakatan Rakyat (PR) sharing equal support from the remaining voters.

The ban on Hindraf was lifted on the eve of Thaipusam, a significant festival to the Tamils who make up the majority of Malaysian Indians, just as the 13th general election draws near.

The Indian vote is seen as crucial in determining BN’s continued rule as the approaching election, which must be called by April, is expected to be a very tight battle between the ruling coalition and PR.

The MIC said last month that it was banking on Najib’s popularity to recapture Indian support.

Observers have said that Najib and BN leaders have lost confidence in the MIC’s ability to score the Indian vote, resulting in efforts by the prime minister to engage directly with the community, who form nearly 1.8 million of the 28 million-strong population in Malaysia. Some 800,000 are registered voters.

Deputy Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin announced last Saturday that the government would provide a special budget for Tamil schools next year, on top of the RM100 million allocation in Budget 2012 and 2013 each.

Under Budget 2013, Najib also allocated RM50 million for Indian entrepreneurs and another RM50 million to train impoverished Indian students in industrial skills.

Putrajaya also dished out RM500 cash aids under the Bantuan Rakyat 1 Malaysia (BR1M) programme last year that cost taxpayers RM2.6 billion, a move that increased Najib’s approval ratings to 69 per cent.

A second round of BR1M this year is expected to benefit 4.3 million households and 2.7 million single unmarried individuals compared to 4.2 million people for the first BR1M.

Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) political analyst Dr Sivamurugan Pandian told The Malaysian Insider that the past 16 by-elections indicated the return of Indian backing for BN, especially among rural voters.

“Hulu Selangor was owned back by (P.) Kamalanathan,” he said, referring to the Hulu Selangor by-election in 2010 that the MIC’s Kamalanathan won after party lost the seat to PKR in Election 2008.

“I think in the next general election, Indians will evaluate the performance of the four (PR) state governments and what Najib has been doing for the Indian community in the past,” Sivamurugan said.

He also said that the lifting of the ban on Hindraf may persuade some fence-sitters over to BN who viewed it as a sign of political change.

“We’ve seen certain conditions, restrictions being imposed on an organisation or even to assemble, but today we see the changes that have occurred. So maybe this is part of his (Najib’s) plan so that people will be able to see there is change,” said Sivamurugan.

Like Wong, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) political analyst Datuk Dr Shamsul Amri Baharuddin also said that the lifting of the Hindraf ban was largely insignificant to Indian voters.

“Lower-class and lower-caste Indians who have directly benefited from BN’s recent concerted efforts to help the poor have returned to BN,” Shamsul Amri told The Malaysian Insider via a text message yesterday.

“You must remember Hindraf is a movement initiated by the middle and upper-class/ caste Indians by mobilising the lower-class/caste Indians. Now the latter (the majority in Hindraf) has been taken care of to an extent. The former (small number) who are well-off will remain defiant for ‘democratic reasons’,” he added.

Another UKM political analyst, Datuk Dr Mohammad Agus Yusoff, said the lifting of the ban on Hindraf would not pull many Indian voters back to BN as the group was not significant anymore.

“Hindraf has been out of the picture for some time,” Mohammad Agus told The Malaysian Insider.

“What are the determining factors that could influence Indians to vote in the general election? I think it’s about their livelihood, cost of living, fairness, social justice. I think that is what they are looking for, not so much about Hindraf being illegal or not,” he added.

Hindraf leaders said last Saturday that being legal now was “nothing to celebrate about”, vowing instead to continue pursuing the demands they raised before Election 2008, an election that saw BN lose its customary two-thirds parliamentary majority.

Key among these demands are equal rights and opportunities for all races in Malaysia and the scrapping of Article 153 of the Federal Constitution, which outlines the special privileges and position of the Malays.


  1. Nowadays we read things like this —— acc to political,,economic etc analyst giving their views BUT WE FAIL TO UNDERSTAND THAT THESE SO CALLED ANALYST ARE NOT THAT GREAT FELLOWS IN THE SENSE THAT IN MOST CASES THIS MUST HAVE BEEN THEIR 1ST OR 2ND ASSIGNMENT.
    coming TO THE ABOVE ARTICLE if u look at the comments 1 look will tell u they are all talking rubbish come on fellas for 55 ++ years Barisan has ruled this country please do not tell me only in the 13th general election they know that the Indians are left behind in the economic pie whereas people who have not contributed to Malaya & later Malaysia coming from a underdeveloped state to a developing country & soon to a developed country are GIVEN BLUE ID CARD ,CAN VOTE IN A GENERAL ELECTION & ARE CITIZENS OF MALAYSIA whereas these poor illiterate fellas who were brought in by the British to develop this country were left ROT,AND THE SO CALLED MIC THAT IS SUPPOSE TO TAKE CARE OF THEIR WELFARE ALSO forgot about these fellas for they were busy filling up their own pockets.,so because of the FRUSTRATION WAS BORN HINDRAF .IN THE SAME WAY HOW THE VIET CON GUERRILLA took its birth with its leader as HO CHIN MING .IN North VIETNAM LEADING TO THE FORMATION OF Vietnam,in the same way hindraf has taken on its shoulders legal or illegal to solve the problems of this group they are on the right tract when 300,00 people are left to rot is that nation called a developed nation come 2020 sorry bro come out of the well .

    Comment by Selva Nathan — January 29, 2013 @ 9:59 AM | Reply

    • Selva, spot on.

      Comment by Lim Yung Keng — January 29, 2013 @ 10:35 AM | Reply

  2. Indians in Malaysia will continue to suffer because they are easily duped by freebies like BR1M. That is what Hindraf can get them? Looks like Najib knew how to tickle their sweet spot.

    Comment by AS — January 29, 2013 @ 9:17 AM | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: