Hornbill Unleashed

April 3, 2014

Sarawak biggest challenge: NCR issues, court rulings

Filed under: Politics — Hornbill Unleashed @ 7:00 AM
Tags: , , , , ,

FMT Staff

Borneo Resource Institute said although NCR was recognised by the state government under the Sarawak Land Code, there were weaknesses in the definition of terms.

The continuous conflicts over land in the state is because of the vague and weak definition of  native customary rights (NCR) and the Sarawak Land Code, said Borneo Resource Institute (Brimas).

According to Brimas executive director Mark Bujang, this is also the reason why more than 300 NCR land related cases are pending in court.

Citing the Penan community as an example, Bujang said certain quarters in the government believe that this group have no NCR rights because they are nomadic.

“But the fact is even though they are always ‘roaming’, traditionally the Penans live in the forest and have  their own distinct territory.

“The challenge is when the executive — the state government –  does not want to follow the recent court judgement.

“There are more than 20 cases such as Nor Nyawai, Madeli Salleh and Tuai Rumah Sandah, in which the courts have decided that NCR is not confined only to Temuda (farmed land) but also Pemakai Menoa (communal land)  and Pulau Galau (reserved land).

“The indigenous communities say that Pulau Galau, Pemakai Menoa and Temuda are NCR.

“But the state government only recognizes Temuda (farmed land). This is the source of conflict,” he said.

Bujang was presenting a paper on the ‘Indigenous people’s role in traditional forest conservation and governance in Sarawak’ at a Capacity Building Workshop on Forest Watch Initiative in Sarawak organised by Transparency International Malaysia here yesterday.

He said although NCR was recognised by the state government under the Sarawak Land Code, there were some weaknesses in the definition of terms that needed to be accepted, understood and resolved.

“The other weakness that the state faced is weak enforcement. We can see there are a lot of reports lodged with the enforcement agencies (on land matters).

“But there is either no action taken or the action is weak,” he said.

Urgent need for a tribunal

He also touched on the contentious proposal to build 12 hydropower dams.

“The issue is not about how many dams (are built) but whether the communities affected have consented to the construction of dams and how will the implementation of the projects be,” he said.

He added that the state was striving towards industrialisation through Sarawak Corridor of Renewable Energy (SCORE) and that large tracts of forest are being cleared and in some cases converted into oil palm plantations.

Bearing this in mind, he said the indigenous communities recommended that a pre-site survey be conducted before there is any issuance of logging and forest plantation licenses to determine whether the communities have rights over the land.

He said what is urgently needed is for the government to set up a commission or tribunal to look into the current legislation and land/forestry policies with regards to NCR in line with what the courts have already decided.

“The government should set up a commission or tribunal to look into this. This was proposed by Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak (Tan Sri Panglima) Richard Malanjum last year.

“He said there should be a body looking into the matter of NCR disputes because there are not enough lawyers and experts to deal with this issue,” Bujang said.

He also urged the state government to respect the demands and wishes of the indigenous people when developing their territories.

“It is not necessary that the government has to decide for the community. They now have the capacity to decide what sort of development that they want on their own.

“If there is any development that has negative impact on the communities, we urge the state government to halt it.

“Call for a dialogue session and meeting to engage the communities before proceeding with the project,” he said.


1 Comment »

  1. The state gov’t should not deliberately go against the courts decisions pertaining to the ownership rights of natives to their customary lands. The gov’t should not continue to protect the interests of the rich few who are deeply involve in the gov’t mischeivious plans to commercialise natives lands including the Pulau Galau and Pemakai menua in light of the courts decisions which clearly recognised the natives claims and right of ownership to these lands.

    These lands will be permanently owned by these rich few if these lands do not revert to the majority natives in the very near future. Meaning, all of Sarawak lands will be owned by a few non native rich people and corporations!

    And that is very dangerous path to trade if the gov’t is to persue a harmoneous co-existance between the natives and non natives in Sarawak.

    The few incidents where lives were lost is a sinister signs or rather foretelling of bitter and more destructive conflicts between natives,gov’t and those rich few who are unwilling to accept the fact that they have to surrender back what is not rightfully theirs in the begining to the rightful owners!

    Comment by brian — April 3, 2014 @ 12:53 PM | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: