Hornbill Unleashed

January 11, 2017

Four issues that GE14 will make clear

Filed under: Politics — Hornbill Unleashed @ 8:01 AM

GE14The BN will have a better chance of winning if a snap general election is held, according to an analyst.

And a convincing BN victory would mean former prime minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s full retirement from politics, says Dr Norshahril Saat, a Fellow at the Iseas-Yusof Ishak Institute in Singapore.

Norshahril, who researches on politics in Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia, says the 14th general election will be a defining year for Malaysian politics.

Most analysts, he notes, expect the GE to be held in the second half of this year, although it is due only in August 2018.

The outcome of the general election , he says in a comment piece on Today Online, will make at least four political issues and situations clear:

  • For the ruling Barisan Nasional, the election is a test of its ability to recover from the 1Malaysia Development Berhad scandal;
  • It will also be a test of the cooperation between Umno, the MCA, and the MIC, and give an indication of whether ethnic-based parties remain relevant;
  • For the opposition, the election is a yardstick of its unity and competence. GE14 is the opposition’s best chance of beating BN, after it made huge gains in the last election by narrowly beating the ruling party in popular votes.
  • It will also be a test of Dr Mahathir’s popularity and relevance in Malaysian politics. If the opposition, fails to win, it could mean the end of Dr Mahathir’s era.

Norshahril notes that even though Dr Mahathir stepped down as prime minister in 2003, he had not quit politics. He has continued to voice his opinions against the government and was instrumental in getting his successor Abdullah Ahmad Badawi to resign in favour of Najib Razak.

Last year, Dr Mahathir formed an opposition party – the Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia.

“Today, some opposition members regard Dr Mahathir as their best hope of toppling BN. It is also ironic that Dr Mahathir is the man tasked with saving an opposition coalition that had started out trying to overthrow him.

“Dr Mahathir’s efforts to reunite the opposition have made some inroads, but his authoritarian past continues to haunt him.”

Norshahril gives the example of Dr Mahathir’s new-found friendship with arch nemesis Lim Kit Siang of the DAP, and Anwar Ibrahim, whom he had sacked as deputy prime minister, to show how there are no permanent enemies in politics and “how quickly Malaysian politicians can jump ship and change tack, out of political expediency”.

Norshahril also points out how, Umno, also for political expediency, has throughout 2016 “increasingly played up the racial and religious cards more prominently and is edging closer to the Islamic opposition party Parti Islam Se-Malaysia (PAS)”.

He notes that at the most recent Umno general assembly, Najib warned the Malays that if the party lost the next election, the secularist, Chinese-dominated Democratic Action Party (DAP) would rule Malaysia.

There was a time when Umno and PAS were going for each other’s throats but there appears to be some sort of understanding between them for the moment.

He observes: “Malaysian politicians can seem to bury the hatchet quicker than many Malaysians.”

Saying the opposition has yet to resolve several pressing issues, he adds, Malaysians will not consider the opposition as serious contenders to form the federal government unless it can agree on a shadow Cabinet.

Source : @ FMT Online


1 Comment »

  1. Discontent in Malay heartland may spell trouble for PM Najib
    By Emily Chow| SUNGKAI, Malaysia

    SUNGKAI, Malaysia The Malaysian plantation district of Sungkai has become an initial – and unlikely – battleground for an election that embattled Prime Minister Najib Razak is expected to call this year.

    Sungkai is home to ethnic Malays who work for the national palm plantation operator, Federal Land Development Authority (Felda). Known as “Felda settlers”, they have long been among the beneficiaries of government affirmative action programmes for Malays, who form the majority of the population.

    The Felda settlers have been a rock solid vote bank for Najib’s ruling coalition, even as urban Malays have poured into the opposition camp in recent years, alienated by a series of political scandals.

    Najib’s coalition lost the popular vote in the last general election in 2013, but still won a majority of seats in Malaysia’s gerrymandered constituencies.

    Malaysia’s opposition is hoping the settlers could be the next to defect, which was why opposition lawmaker Rafizi Ramli on Sunday night was in Sungkai, a former mining town that now mainly relies on palm oil and rubber planting.

    The settlers have been angered by Felda’s decision to purchase a 37 percent stake in Indonesian palm oil firm PT Eagle High Plantations (BWPT.JK) for $505 million, more than a 100 percent premium based on its closing share price on Wednesday.


    Eagle High is owned by one of Indonesia’s richest men, Peter Sondakh, who has done a number of deals in Malaysia and is a longtime friend of Najib.

    Najib’s office did not respond to requests for comment about the deal. Sondakh has not publicly commented about the deal in Jakarta.

    Just six months ago, Najib’s United Malays National Organisation (UMNO) party secured a sweeping victory in a by-election in this constituency in northern Perak state.

    But on Sunday night, more than 300 people gathered on the lawn of a Sungkai resident under a dank tropical night to hear opposition lawmaker Rafizi Ramli tell the cheering crowd: “We will change our prime minister and our government.”

    “Felda’s debts are growing … and the government will use the settlers money to pay it off,” said Rafizi, a 39-year-old lawmaker from People’s Justice Party (PKR).

    “If we don’t stop this, the debt will be shouldered by our future generations.”

    Felda has said the deal will not impact its existing commitments and programmes to improve the well-being of the settlers. Felda itself is planning a series of roadshows to convince settlers in its plantation areas of the deal’s benefits.


    Felda settlers are the majority voters in at least 54 of the 222 seats in the national parliament, and has helped bring the UMNO-led Barisan Nasional (National Front) coalition to power in every election since independence in 1957.

    Even the opposition’s attempt to highlight a multi-billion dollar alleged money-laundering scandal at state investment fund 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) that erupted in 2015 did not resonate with rural voters.

    The Felda issue, however, affects them directly.

    “All this while, UMNO has won the elections because there are 54 parliamentary seats in the Felda (settlers) areas. Now I am sure the sentiment has changed,” said Mazlan Aliman, president of the National Felda Settlers’ Children Society (ANAK).

    He estimates that over half of his association members and their families will vote for the opposition party if the Eagle High deal goes through. “If this happens, (Barisan Nasional) will lose in the upcoming elections,” Mazlan said.

    Najib has to call elections by 2018, but a government source told Reuters he may do it earlier, possibly in the second half of this year.


    The prime minister is heading into the next election already saddled with the scandal around 1MDB, which has been investigated in a half-dozen countries for money laundering. His government said nearly $700 million of 1MDB money that wound up in Najib’s personal bank account came from an unnamed Saudi.

    Yet Najib, who has steadfastly denied any wrongdoing, retains a tight grip on UMNO by commanding a vast patronage system that spreads the largesse among ordinary Malays as well as party apparatchiks.

    He is wielding sticks along with the carrots: Anwar Ibrahim, the charismatic opposition leader, remains in jail on sodomy charges, activists and politicians have been charged with sedition, critical news websites have been closed.

    Rafizi, the lawmaker who spoke at the Sungkai rally, is himself on bail pending an appeal after he was sentenced to 18 months in jail for leaking a confidential 1MDB document.

    But the prime minister is fighting economic headwinds. The ringgit currency has fallen by more than a quarter over the past two years, prices have risen after state subsidies were slashed and a national goods and services (GST) tax launched, and economic growth is expected to slow in 2017.

    All that is being felt in rural Malay heartlands such as Sungkai, and is contributing to the sour faces over the Felda-Eagle High deal.


    Felda, created by Najib’s father and Malaysia’s second prime minister, resettled and employed the rural poor in the palm industry. It helped lead Malaysia to become one of the world’s two largest producers of palm oil, along with Indonesia.

    The settlers leased government land for palm cultivation and many also own shares in Felda Global Ventures (FGV) (FGVH.KL), a unit of Felda that raised over $3 billion in a listing in 2012.

    But Felda’s fortunes have slumped in recent years – its shares fell by over 60 percent since its IPO. The shares plunged another 5 percent on Dec. 23, when the Eagle High deal was announced.

    “This is a waste of money,” said Khalili Kasim, a 64-year-old settler, saying Felda should be providing housing loans, or educational aid instead of putting money into Eagle High.

    “Land owners should be rich, but why are some of us still struggling and living under the poverty line?” Khalili said.

    But the opposition will be fighting an uphill battle to secure the votes of Felda settlers, who have long been loyal UMNO supporters.

    “In the lead-up to the elections, if they (UMNO) can develop measures that can persuade the voters … then they can still mitigate the concerns arising from the purchase of Eagle High,” said Ibrahim Suffian, director of independent opinion polling firm Merdeka Center.

    “But this is not a done deal; it is a developing story.”

    (Editing by Praveen Menon and Bill Tarrant)

    Comment by jk han — January 12, 2017 @ 9:09 AM | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: