Hornbill Unleashed

August 2, 2009

Absolutely NO to ISA…on a lazy Malaysian Sunday

By Sim Kwang Yang

Abolish ISAAs I write, at 4.30pm on Saturday afternoon, following news of the anti-ISA protest in down town Kuala Lumpur on the Internet, I can imagine how the city centre 8 miles away from my Cheras home has turned into a war zone.

The protesters numbering in the tens of thousands must be playing hide and seek with the massive police presence there.  In the past few hours, the Police have arrested hundreds of protesters in various parts of the city.  The chemical-laced water canons and tear gas have been deployed, but the crowds do not seem to have been intimidated.

The hectic chaos in KL city centre is reminiscent of the massive protest about 10 years ago after the arrest and detention of Anwar Ibrahim.  The happy days of POLITIK JALANRAYA are back again.

ISA Protest1In past days and especially to-day, the city traffic has been trapped in a gridlock. There will be disgruntled shopkeepers and motorists who will complain about the great inconvenience and loss of income caused by the protest.  These grumblings will probably be magnified in the mainstream media to-morrow.

Meanwhile, the Prime Minister has commented that the anti-ISA protest is unnecessary because the authorities are in the process of reviewing this much hated law.

They still do not get it.  The government cannot be trusted to take care of everything; the people must be allowed room in public space on the streets of KL to express their extreme contempt for this law in peaceful manners.  This is called people exercising their democratic rights to free assembly and free expression.

Abolish ISA1I was a little apprehensive that there was a simultaneous pro-ISA protest organised by PERWARIS, a group of Muslim NGOs under the aegis of Ibrahim Ali the Frog.  He was himself detained under the ISA twice.  But this rally seems insignificant, compared to the huge anti-ISA crowd.

The protesters in KL on Saturday have bravely step forth to face down the police boldly against everything bad about the ISA.  The very fact that they are prepared to put their bodies in harm’s way is an indication of their resolve to have this unjust law banished to the rubbish bin of history.

ISA arrest1I see those pictures of Police arresting the protesters.  Those men do not appear afraid; in fact, the look quite proud of themselves, as they should be.

The ISA was legislated in 1960, giving the police many ultra-constitutional powers to arrest and detain people indefinitely without trial.  The rationale was that the Police needed those powers to fight a shadowy communist armed insurgency.

I had hated it from the beginning, even when I was a teenager growing up in troubled Sarawak.  It just seemed offensive to my young sense of civilised decency.

ISA arrestThe Communist insurgency has since been defeated, and yet the ISA continued to be used by the BN government to detain and arrest their political foes in the opposition as well as vocal dissidents, government critics, and NGO activists.

The giant shadow of the ISA, like Bentham’s panopticon, imposed a regime of fear among Malaysians of all shapes and persuasions, limiting the people’s mind to the exclusive brain-control programmes through the schools and the mainstream media.

Fortunately, new generations of young Malaysians have been born.  They grow up without the memories or personal experience of the communist insurgency or the 1987 Operation Lalang.

ISA Protest2They have been awakened and motivated by the new reform agenda that transcends race and religion.  Above all, they are better informed by the alternative media of the Internet.  The mind-control that used to work so well through the traditional media is now much despised.

I look back to the time 30 years ago, when I first took part in active politics.  People were fearful.  Even my own relatives and friends were afraid to be seen with me in public.

I remember an Iban friend who had a Ph. D.  I was trying to recruit him into politics. He asked me all the questions, including the pay for an MP, and what perks there were.  Finally he asked about the ISA.  I had to tell him that arrest under the ISA is always a possibility for people in the opposition political frontline.  He said he could not handle that, and so he stayed out of politics.

ISA ProtestLooking at the dramatic images streaming from malaysiakini by the hour now, I am happy.  Malaysia has changed for the better, even though the government has not.  There are so many young people of all races ready to face arrest just to try to change the future of this country.  I could not dream of this happening 30 or 20 years ago.

To-night, hundreds of these people will have to spend their night in a police lock up.  It is just a small inconvenience for a noble cause.  It is also a badge of honour for anyone wanting to be publicly engaged to change the destiny of this country.

POLITIK JALANRAYAI hope none will die in police detention to-night, or else that would be cause for another larger mass rally on the streets of KL.

Let us share solidarity with those concerned brave souls on the streets of KL, and spread this message through cyber-sphere:-

Absolutely no to ISA!

😦

(SKY can be reached at kenyalang578@hotmail.com )

😦

15 Comments »

  1. Nobly said, SKY! I was unable to be physically in KL yesterday but my heart was out in the streets with all of them, cheering their courage and feeling outraged by every arrest, every can of tear gas, every blast of the water cannon. Imagine, these crowd control vehicles cost around RM350,000 each. How could it have happened that we set up the police force and hand them billions annually to buy more sophisticated tools of repression against ourselvces and our children? It’s absurd!

    Comment by Antares — August 3, 2009 @ 12:01 AM | Reply

  2. SKY,

    Forget about kadir jasin!! He is a real UMNo mongrel here, worse than any street dog that you’ll ever find. My reply to his article in his blog was totally black out! You judge for yourself if what I wrote is offensive?

    “”The UMNO struggle has always been a class struggle. It has never been for under privilege Malays. It’s to keep the general Malays population ignorant,so that the Malay upper class, namely the UMNoputras’ will have a monopoly on political power and hence the total control of the Nation’s Wealth. Ketuana Melayu, it’s just a very convenient excuse.

    See how those MCA Chinese made the killings in the PKFZ project. If Ketuanan Melayu rhetoric really mean anything for the ordinary Malays, the government would not let those bastards get away with such blatant disregard for the law of the country!

    If not for the 308 election tsunami, the number of opposition members of parliment would be few and hence would be shouted down or totally shut up by the dewan speaker! Nobody would have known any thing about PKFZ case. Barisan Nasional are but a bunch of pirates using divide and rule tactic.

    As a non-Malay I demand that the government go after those involved in the swindled of 12 billions of the rakyat tax money and stop shouting ketunan Melayu untill foaming at the mouth while protecting MCA running dogs the swindle the taxpayers. Don’t worry, we will not complain of discrimination against the Chinese this time. A crime is a crime and the criminals behind must be brought to justice, there’s nothing racial about it.

    Sigh, almost forgot those bastards are UMNo’s partners in crime, so nothing will be done.””

    Comment by StevenO — August 2, 2009 @ 7:52 PM | Reply

  3. SKY,

    Forget about kadir jasin!!He is a real UMNo dog, worse than any street dog that you’ll ever find. My reply to his article in his blog was totally black out! You judge for yourself if what I wrote is offensive?

    “”The UMNO struggle has always been a class struggle. It has never been for under privilege Malays. It’s to keep the general Malays population ignorant,so that the Malay upper class, namely the UMNoputras’ will have a monopoly on political power and hence the total control of the Nation’s Wealth. Ketuana Melayu, it’s just a very convenient excuse.

    See how those MCA Chinese made the killings in the PKFZ project. If Ketuanan Melayu rhetoric really mean anything for the ordinary Malays, the government would not let those bastards get away with such blatant disregard for the law of the country!

    If not for the 308 election tsunami, the number of opposition members of parliment would be few and hence would be shouted down or totally shut up by the dewan speaker! Nobody would have known any thing about PKFZ case. Barisan Nasional are but a bunch of pirates using divide and rule tactic.

    As a non-Malay I demand that the government go after those involved in the swindled of 12 billions of the rakyat tax money and stop shouting ketunan Melayu untill foaming at the mouth while protecting MCA running dogs the swindle the taxpayers. Don’t worry, we will not complain of discrimination against the Chinese this time. A crime is a crime and the criminals behind must be brought to justice, there’s nothing racial about it.

    Sigh, almost forgot those bastards are UMNo’s partners in crime, so nothing will be done.””

    Comment by StevenO — August 2, 2009 @ 7:49 PM | Reply

  4. Whatever the print media reports take it with a pinch of salt as they are under the scutiny of the ISA. How then are we to learn the truth> Two pro ISA dermonatractions were called off because he Govt told them to. Very obedient indeed. Can you swallow that explanation? Police very tough and efficient because they have the weapons. Did the demonstrators demolish and proterty like Dato Dr. Rias Yatim did? NMNO will be defeated in the next election as we cannot stand their cover up with lies after lies. RPK to be detained under the ISA because the Govt. is scared of the truth. Why not put him on trial so that he can defend himself?

    Comment by lkm — August 2, 2009 @ 6:17 PM | Reply

  5. I can only say, that this is the demonstration of cowards. Would you wack a child with a stick if he did wrong with his bare hands fall short of killing someone with his bare hands?
    But Malaysian police did it to innocent people who just wanted to be a little boisterous with nothing in hand.
    Can you imagine if the crowd were armed like those in Thailand and Philippines.
    Looking at the crowd I should say if they were armed they were ready to die.
    And I say it is going to happen one day, in the not too distant future.Don’t push a cornered dog to the edge, it will bite and then fall off, but the falling off will make the bite bigger

    Comment by paulandrews — August 2, 2009 @ 5:38 PM | Reply

  6. Sim, what are you doing at home? I have a knee problem and nerve compression and I still went. Both of these symptoms do not allow me to walk very far or stand very long, neither running away fast from the gas canister or water cannon. The Hindraf heroes were so strong, they stand-up against the chemical laced water cannon. It is really painful and burning, I was in tears. There were young children and babies among the victims.

    I was approached and people acknowledge me and asked the same questions many times. “Why so few Chinese came?”. I felt very difficult to answer that question. Sometimes, when chinese were told to “Balik China”, chinese get offended from that comment. But when it comes to show 1Malaysia or as a Chinese Malaysian, very few turn up. If you don’t turn up and fight for your right, yeah… might as well go back to China.

    I went… because I love my country, Malaysia. Saya Anak Malaysia.

    Comment by Wave33 — August 2, 2009 @ 5:27 PM | Reply

    • you are great, and i kalah, becauee you were there, and i was not. You win, I lose. I hear you loud and clear.

      Comment by sky — August 3, 2009 @ 2:03 AM | Reply

  7. I wonder if the chicken power culprits who keep pet stray dogs to accompany them, may have happened to wrongly endanger people they may not that clear who they are, probably, IN FUTURE. This world is round and people are well-linked. We are 1 INTERNATIONAL family. Accidents continue to happen. It is hard to say, anything can happen from this blessed Sunday onwards. If there is the case, It will be very fun to see the culprits struggle their last breath before the next Tsunami. Make them the guniea-pigs in Science Lab, think of new experiments to play on them. Human beings always think too highly of themselves as they think they are the living Gods who can overpower anything or any species. So let them excessively excercise their arrogance to NO LIMITS. Once they fully aggravate the almighty power, well, they will be greeted BONJOUR in a place where they can only see fire burning! I wonder who dares to go to that place and collect their ashes? It is deep, deep, deep down the ground!

    Sayonara! Get a Mocha for this lazy afternoon.

    Comment by Minnie Mouse — August 2, 2009 @ 2:26 PM | Reply

  8. The main potency of the ISA was as a weapon of fear and this effect was even more important than actual detentions. Mahathir knew how to manage this weapon, he used it with devastating effect.

    Due to mismanagement of the ISA weapon under Pak Lah epitomized by the foolish detention of Sin Chew journalist Tan Hoon Cheng and DAP MP Teresa Kok, the fear factor has largely dissipated. The ISA is now ridiculed and those put under ISA consider it a badge of honour and a sure route to gaining popularity such as the Hindraf 5.

    Any ISA detention create so much bad publicity for the govt that using the ISA on anybody other than real terrorists is now no longer politically acceptable. If RPK returns, the govt can hardly return him to Kamunting without suffering more political backlash than he is worth. Even worse, any political ISA detainee gains instant fame and sympathy as well as a platform to attack the govt.

    If the BN govt is smart they will see the pointlessness of clinging to a weapon which can hardly be used these days. They may as well gain some brownie points by abolishing it and introducing an anti-terrorism act.

    The ISA represents yet another weapon down for the BN govt, just like ethnic fear and Chinese fear of PAS, they have been superseded by events and changing times.

    Comment by Kenny — August 2, 2009 @ 12:47 PM | Reply

  9. Najib came out with quite typical rhetoric, worthy of his moral stature: basically, “I told you so”.

    He said “We want to advise them, but they won’t listen… It is up to the police if arrests are made, we need to leave it to the authorities.”

    Come off it. Najib and Hishamuddin ARE the authorities. The police wouldn’t even wash their backsides if the bosses didn’t allow them to.

    Najib is trying to sound paternalistic, and to sound concerned about the protestors. That’s why he warned Malaysians not to gather. I suppose this “concern” extends to policemen assaulting a Member of Parliament, PAS’s Dr Hatta Ramli. They scratched his arm and tore off his shirt. Dr Hatta said he had never seen such repulsive police thuggery in all his years of participating in public demonstrations.

    Any self-respecting Home Minister and Police Inspector General would resign.

    Comment by Pak Bui — August 2, 2009 @ 12:06 PM | Reply

  10. Today The Star published a picture of the anti-ISA crowd on its front page. Such pictures are prohibited during Mahathir’s time, another sign that things have changed.

    First hand accounts from those who took part said it was a multi-racial crowd. This is yet another eye opener as previously the Chinese do not participate in this sort of rallies.

    Comment by Kenny — August 2, 2009 @ 12:02 PM | Reply

    • After what happen to Teoh Beng Hock? It could be their children or their grandchildren in the future. Yeah, chinese is always lay back type only concern about their bank account. Majority of chinese is still is especially those whom has projects from BN.

      Comment by Wave33 — August 2, 2009 @ 9:46 PM | Reply

  11. I believe the crowds will run up to 100k ,if Police have not set up road blocks at major highways leading to the city centre.
    Mass Voices must be heard and taken seriously .Tear gas will not deter the many brave souls to fight for what is right.
    I finally feel proud again to be Malaysian and I can walk tall because of this brave warriors.1st August marks a significant milestone to get rid of ISA in Malaysia.I hope the hundreds did have a good sleep in the police lock up.You have made all malaysians proud.A small price to pay for a worthy deed.Well done and may the alimighty bless your souls and your family good health and happiness always in the name of democracy you stand up for.

    Comment by Hgwells — August 2, 2009 @ 10:18 AM | Reply

  12. My hat and salute goes out to all those brave young men and women who stood unashamedly and boldly and put themselves in harm’s way for a noble cause. 01st August can be defined as another turning moment in Malaysi’s history in our struggle for a more meaningful role of democracy. Typically, it’s this Government again attempting their vile and threatening manner to stamp out the common voice of dissent. We need to carry this momentum through. The Malaysian rakyat must not be driven into submission against the forces of tear gas and water cannons. We can take up the challenges. The struggle comes from what our hearts believe to be right. And if this Government is so insensitive to let us express them openly, we shall be even more determined to rally the cause till the finishing line.

    Comment by malsia1206 — August 2, 2009 @ 12:51 AM | Reply

    • For a damper, you should read kadir jasin’s blog. But then, what do you expect from him, who has benefited from the stupid government policies.

      Comment by sky — August 2, 2009 @ 6:43 AM | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.